1. La Carta Abierta de 1948 y la Comparación con el Nazismo.
El tema más recurrente es la resistencia judía al sionismo desde 1948, marcada por una carta abierta al New York Times firmada por Hannah Arendt, Albert Einstein y otros. Esta carta comparaba las tácticas y la filosofía política del recién formado gobierno israelí (o facciones específicas como el Herut de Menachem Begin) con las de los partidos nazis y fascistas.
- Jews have resisted zionism since 1948 when hannah arendt, einstein etc wrote an open letter to the nyt. It cf the newly formed israeli gov to nazis in methods, organisation, political philosophy social appeal.
- Jews have a long history of resisting zionism. In 1948 when arendt einstein cfed the newly formed israeli gov to the nazis in organisation, methods, political philosophy, social appeal.
- Did you know? einstein tried to warn the world about zionism jewish terrorism, in april 1948. Einstein open letter to the new york times criticized menachem begins herut freedom party for the deir yassin massacre attributed to terrorist bands likened herut to the nazi fascist parties.
- If arendt and einstein were alive today, youd be calling them self-hating jews. They had no use for the fascist bend of revisionist zionism.
2. La Advertencia de Einstein sobre el Neo-Fascismo.
Albert Einstein es citado repetidamente como una figura que advirtió que el sionismo, especialmente en su vertiente nacionalista, se convertiría en un vehículo para el neo-fascismo. Se le atribuyen frases que equiparan el sionismo con una nueva forma de fascismo, y se señala que su crítica se centró en la violencia etnonacionalista y la traición a la ética judía.
- I mean, zionism was always intended to be ethno-fascist, and even jews like einstein knew this would happen and warned against it.
- Its as though albert einstein was right when he said zionism was just a new form of fascism.
- No less than albert einstein warned that zionism would lead again to neo-fascism and here we are. As netanyahu protects his corruption with ethnic cleansing.
- It makes sense. Zionism is the jewish wing of antisemitism, at least according to einstein.
- Albert einstein, a jew, warned the u.s. Of the threat of zionism.
3. La Postura Nuanceada de Einstein: Sionismo Cultural vs. Estado Nacionalista.
Existe un debate constante sobre la identidad sionista de Einstein. Mientras algunos afirman que murió siendo sionista (laborista o cultural), otros insisten en que rechazó la creación del Estado de Israel. La mayoría de las referencias coinciden en que él apoyaba un hogar judío en Palestina, pero se oponía a un estado mayoritario judío con ejército, prefiriendo una solución binacional o un sionismo basado en la coexistencia y la cultura.
- Einstein was a zionist who believed jews have a right to live in their homeland. Thats all zionism is.
- Einstein was a binationalist who supported a vision of cultural zionism that would not necessitate jewish majoritarian state.
- I made the cause of zionism mine because through it i saw a means of correcting a flagrant wrong, einstein wrote in a 1947 letter to indian prime minister jawaharlal nehru.
- Einstein on zionism he is for a jewish homeland, but not a separate state. January 21, 1946.
- Albert einstein was famously a zionist supporter of a jewish homeland but not a jewish state.