1. Definiciones Contrapuestas de Sionismo.
El término "Sionismo" es objeto de una profunda disputa. Mientras que una parte lo define como el derecho a la autodeterminación judía en su tierra ancestral, la otra lo equipara con ideologías de supremacía, colonialismo y genocidio.
- Zionism is the belief that the jewish people have a right to self-determination in their indigenous homeland.
- Zionism is colonialism, apartheid, genocide, racism. You cannot separate zionism from any of those.
- Zionism is the affirmation of jewish indigenous existence.
- Zionism is jewish supremacy though. Thats what it actually is. Thats why it has an ethno aparthied state jewish supremacy.
2. La Confluencia Peligrosa: Sionismo y Judaísmo.
Un punto central del debate es la insistencia en separar o unir la ideología política del Sionismo con la religión y la identidad cultural judía. La equiparación es frecuentemente calificada como una táctica antisemita que pone en peligro a los judíos de la diáspora.
- Conflating zionism with judaism is anti-semitism.
- Continuing to conflate zionism with jewishness will have the inevitable consequence of increasing actual antisemitism. You are actively putting jewish people in danger.
- Judaism is not zionism. Zionism is a political ideology from its inception.
- Zionism is a political ideology. Not an identity. And a large portion of jewish people are anti zionist.
3. La Postura Pro-Sionista: Anti-Sionismo es Antisemitismo.
Para muchos adherentes, el Sionismo representa la seguridad y la legitimidad de la existencia judía. Desde esta perspectiva, oponerse al Sionismo es negar el derecho de los judíos a la autodeterminación y, por lo tanto, es inherentemente antisemita.
- Anti-zionism is absolutely a form of antisemitism. Zionism is the belief that israel should continue to exist for the safety and self determination of the jews.
- When you attack zionism, you attack jews. Zionism affirms jewish existence.
- Anti-zionism is the movement to destroy the nation of israel and its people. It is the inherently genocidal ideology of islamist terrorism. So you support genocide of jews.
- Zionism is the belief that jews, like any other ethnic group, have a right to self-determination in the place of their ancestors. Being antizionist or criticizing zionism is a tell, in and of itself. You are a nazi.
4. La Postura Anti-Sionista: Ideología Colonial y Racista.
Los críticos, incluyendo a muchos judíos anti-sionistas, argumentan que el Sionismo moderno es una ideología etno-nacionalista, supremacista y colonialista, y que oponerse a estas políticas (genocidio, apartheid) es un imperativo moral, no antisemitismo.
- Zionism is an antisemitic neocolonialist project that is currently being used to justify a genocide against palestinians.
- Zionism is a fascist, nazi, political ideology that has nothing to do with noble judaism.
- Zionism is anti-semitism zionism calls for the ethnic cleansing of a semitic people, palestinians, from their land.
- Zionism is an ethno-fascist movement that uses judaism as a cover for their vile and reprehensible actions.