1. Críticas a la Autoría Femenina en Ficción Queer y Estereotipos.
Existe una fuerte reacción y escepticismo cuando una mujer escribe sobre hombres gay, a menudo acusándola de caer en estereotipos o de tener intenciones fetichistas, mientras que la escritura masculina sobre mujeres es menos cuestionada.
- Given that its written by a woman about gay men im shocked that they didnt go full-on stereotype and call it fanfiction.
- I also find it strange when a woman writes fantasy its more likely to be called romantasy than if a man writes fantasy with the same amount of relationships in it.
- I was just like in the hr feed i saw someone say theyll watch the show bc it was made by a gay man but they wont read the book because it was written by a straight woman and that they dont read mm romance unless a gay man is behind it.
2. Dobles Estándares en el Tratamiento de Personajes Masculinos y Femeninos.
Se percibe que los personajes masculinos son considerados "con matices por defecto", mientras que las mujeres, incluso en roles centrales, son a menudo simplificadas, sexualizadas o su arco narrativo se reduce a su relación con hombres.
- Men are nuanced by default. Get back to me when you think of women the same way.
- Feminizing everything woman character thats not a love interest and still central to the plot, got it.
- When your character arc is literally just woman realizes shes been gaslit by the patriarchy and decides to burn it downrelatable content.
3. La Sobrerrepresentación de Ciertos Tropes en Romance Heterosexual.
El género de romance heterosexual, especialmente el escrito por mujeres, es criticado por depender excesivamente de tropos misóginos como la mujer que se enamora de un hombre mediocre después de ser abusada, o la mujer que debe sacrificarse para salvar al hombre.
- Also because in the mainstream this trope is dominated by heterosexual writers it just looks like a woman who is being verbally abused and often experiencing unwanted touch from a man suddenly decides shes in love with him and thats gross as fuck.
- Theres a different but related discourse happening in romance book fandoms because so many romance plots hinge on the woman doing exactly this kind of shit for a mediocre man.
- One of the most irritating things about straight romances in media is the straight people going aha! i called it! i saw it coming!
4. La Lucha por la Complejidad y la Agencia Femenina en la Ficción.
Hay un deseo expresado por personajes femeninos que puedan ser egoístas, crueles, imperfectas o simplemente existir sin que su identidad se defina únicamente por su sexualidad o su rol en relación con los hombres.
- I think one reason why i dislike most het fanficstories is that a lot of it reads more like being about being wanted by a man rather than being attracted to one.
- I think its sad that society has decided that a woman cant publish a book excerpt where she describes how her sexual awakening came from a pan to a balcony featuring statler and waldorf without getting cancelled.
- I think women characters should be allowed to be selfish and cruel and mean. For plot. Thats fine!! but then its not a story about girl power!
5. La Representación Queer y la Autoría.
Se discute la necesidad de voces queer auténticas en la creación de contenido queer, señalando que la representación escrita por personas ajenas a la experiencia a menudo carece de realismo o cae en la fetichización.
- But a lot of people who are not gay men somehow think theyre great at writing gay representation. Spoilers theyre not.
- I also appreciate the spirit of collaboration where an mlm hockey romance written by a woman is being adapted by a gay male showrunner.
- I also feel since the main gwen we follow in the pilot looks different from other gwens joking about a gwen not fitting the mold of a typical woman feels weird to me.
6. Críticas a la Sexualización y la Mirada Masculina.
La sexualización excesiva de personajes femeninos, especialmente cuando se describe su físico de manera innecesaria o se reduce su valor a su atractivo sexual, es un punto recurrente de frustración.
- And then the age-old problem with cishet male authors every woman in the books has her physicality described according to the male gaze.
- I think i can tell warhound was written by a trans woman because its the two most traumatized people youve seen trying to hold onto something and also sometimes theres sex.
- I think one reason why i dislike most het fanficstories is that a lot of it reads more like being about being wanted by a man rather than being attracted to one.
7. La Carga del Género en la Clasificación y Percepción de Obras.
El género de un autor (ser mujer) influye en cómo se etiqueta y se percibe su obra, a menudo relegándola a categorías como "romantasy" o "chick lit", independientemente del contenido real.
- My debut novel is only categorized in womens because im a woman. Its main characters are men nothing about it has a particular appeal to any gender.
- I also remember reading one with a librarian and a vampire dude and he kept being like ah, silly woman, you must abandon your notions of feminism bc youre with a supernatural being now.
- I also think it says a lot about mikes character! its not just shock value or titillation or an excuse to show a woman doing that!
8. La Mujer como Dispositivo Narrativo o Víctima.
Se critica el uso de mujeres como meros dispositivos para el desarrollo de personajes masculinos (fridging) o como figuras cuya única función es ser un obstáculo o un premio.
- They also make the argument that all of these things were written by and for women, and folks have pointed out that 23 of the authors mentioned here are nonbinary and the other one is a bisexual woman.
- Theyre really trying to be all girl boss with fictional women wanting to have sex with their sons. Why does a woman reclaiming sexual agency mean taking away another persons sexual agency??
- Theyre not even mm to these people they treat viktor as women lite. And because of that here come the barrage of fics where viktor is an actual cis woman.
9. Deseos de Representación Alternativa y Compleja.
Hay un anhelo por ver representaciones más diversas y menos estereotipadas, incluyendo mujeres monstruosas, personajes femeninos egoístas o relaciones donde la mujer es la figura dominante o poderosa sin que esto sea visto como una anomalía.
- I would actually love to see a man loving a woman monster.
- I want to write straight romance as well, but i hate writing women, not because i dislike it but because its hard to write a woman with flaws and try not to think how much more judged shell be compared to the men.
- I like to write woman villainsantagonists more powerful andor aggressive than the man in question because i think too many men are too used to being the most dangerous animal in the room.
10. La Experiencia de Escribir Mujeres.
Las propias escritoras expresan la dificultad y la presión de escribir personajes femeninos, temiendo ser juzgadas por no cumplir con ciertas expectativas o por escribir personajes femeninos que no son "suficientemente" femeninos o "suficientemente" fuertes.
- I think what a lot of men are missing here is that this dynamic exists in two different perspectives men who want to be loved despite their flaws and, women who want to be a fixer andor the only object of desire.
- I think its really nice to finally have women authors and women protagonists i still love ya, men, but representation really does matter.
- I think its really nice to finally have women authors and women protagonists i still love ya, men, but representation really does matter no woman in her right mind goes for a midnight walk to clear her head, thats strictly a guy thing.