1. La Naturaleza de Star Wars como Película de Guerra y Alegoría.
Muchos usuarios ven la saga, especialmente la trilogía original y Rogue One, como inherentemente una película de guerra, a menudo comparándola con conflictos históricos como la Guerra de Vietnam, donde el Imperio representa el imperialismo estadounidense y los Rebeldes al Viet Cong.
- The original star wars is antiwar agitprop dressed up as a war movie that managed to make the term empire synonymous with evil inside of the imperial core.
- Rogue one works because its effectively a 70s war movie disguised as a star wars film.
- Also . The empire in star wars bad guys were an allegory for the us in the vietnam war per george lucas.
- Hell, george lucas said the rebels vs empire conflict was inspired by the vietnam war, with the empire representing us imperialism, and the rebel alliance being the viet cong.
- I really wish theyd make a star wars movie that was like a gritty anti-war story from the point of view of an enlisted or low level officer in the imperial navy, doing special ops against some kind of actually-morally-ambiguous enemy that isnt mainly the rebels.
- I also agree that andor is much better at just about everything.
- Im very surprised to see all this dislike for rogue one, the one actual war movie in star wars.
- Real star war lovers know that rogue one is good star war. If youre judging star war on whether its a good film, youre doing it wrong.
- Rogue one blew my mind. Felt like a real war movie with a tragic end, and the bad robot was hilarious.
- I also love rogue one, its the only star wars movie that feels like a war movie with actual costs see also andor.
- Rebels is the best star war. You get everything deep jedisith religion political upheaval and machinations the beginnings of a revolution the really compelling kanan jarrus, a freddie prinze, jr.-voiced jedi and the coolest droid, chopper.
- The clone wars showed us star wars can do war stories, bits of tlj showed us it could do a heist, episodes in mandalorian were basically 7 samurai.
- Everyone is sleeping on fallen order jedi survivor visions. Animation and video games are a great medium for star war stories.
- One of my favorite moments in the mandalorian was in s2 when you had a western standoff and samurai duel happening side by side lmao. Star wars from the get has a been a mixed of genre.
- The best way to experience star wars has always been the video games.
- Ive always loved how none of the jedi stuff actually affects the outcome of the war one iota in the end.
- And heres the thing about this battle they win it and the overall war! without the aid of a jedi.
- The first order makes sense as a fascist reaction to the outcome of the galactic civil war which wasnt stomped down hard enough by the new liberal order, but ros is still completely batshit.
- Lucas wants us to empathise with anakin. The jedi have lost their way.
- The collapse of the jedi especially when you blend it in with what the clone war animated show teed up was just chefs kiss.
- I never understood why they decided to make the clones fight for the republic. Clone wars implies the jedi were fighting clones, not with with clones.
- Episode i should have ended with the clone wars beginning. Episode ii should have taken place at the height of the war and dived into the stresses it put on the republic, the jedi, and anakin.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.
2. Rogue One: La Película de Guerra Más Pura.
Rogue One es frecuentemente elogiada por ser la entrega que más se acerca a una película de guerra tradicional, destacando su tono sombrío y el sacrificio de sus personajes, aunque algunos critican su ejecución narrativa.
- Im very surprised to see all this dislike for rogue one, the one actual war movie in star wars.
- Real star war lovers know that rogue one is good star war. If youre judging star war on whether its a good film, youre doing it wrong.
- Rogue one blew my mind. Felt like a real war movie with a tragic end, and the bad robot was hilarious.
- I also love rogue one, its the only star wars movie that feels like a war movie with actual costs see also andor.
- Rebels is the best star war. You get everything deep jedisith religion political upheaval and machinations the beginnings of a revolution the really compelling kanan jarrus, a freddie prinze, jr.-voiced jedi and the coolest droid, chopper.
- The clone wars showed us star wars can do war stories, bits of tlj showed us it could do a heist, episodes in mandalorian were basically 7 samurai.
- Everyone is sleeping on fallen order jedi survivor visions. Animation and video games are a great medium for star war stories.
- One of my favorite moments in the mandalorian was in s2 when you had a western standoff and samurai duel happening side by side lmao. Star wars from the get has a been a mixed of genre.
- The best way to experience star wars has always been the video games.
- Ive always loved how none of the jedi stuff actually affects the outcome of the war one iota in the end.
- And heres the thing about this battle they win it and the overall war! without the aid of a jedi.
- The first order makes sense as a fascist reaction to the outcome of the galactic civil war which wasnt stomped down hard enough by the new liberal order, but ros is still completely batshit.
- Lucas wants us to empathise with anakin. The jedi have lost their way.
- The collapse of the jedi especially when you blend it in with what the clone war animated show teed up was just chefs kiss.
- I never understood why they decided to make the clones fight for the republic. Clone wars implies the jedi were fighting clones, not with with clones.
- Episode i should have ended with the clone wars beginning. Episode ii should have taken place at the height of the war and dived into the stresses it put on the republic, the jedi, and anakin.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.
3. Star Wars como Mezcla de Géneros y Medios.
Los usuarios reconocen que la franquicia siempre ha sido una amalgama de géneros, desde westerns y películas de samuráis hasta thrillers de conspiración, y que los videojuegos y la animación son medios efectivos para expandir estas historias.
- Rebels is the best star war. You get everything deep jedisith religion political upheaval and machinations the beginnings of a revolution the really compelling kanan jarrus, a freddie prinze, jr.-voiced jedi and the coolest droid, chopper.
- The clone wars showed us star wars can do war stories, bits of tlj showed us it could do a heist, episodes in mandalorian were basically 7 samurai.
- Everyone is sleeping on fallen order jedi survivor visions. Animation and video games are a great medium for star war stories.
- One of my favorite moments in the mandalorian was in s2 when you had a western standoff and samurai duel happening side by side lmao. Star wars from the get has a been a mixed of genre.
- The best way to experience star wars has always been the video games.
- Ive always loved how none of the jedi stuff actually affects the outcome of the war one iota in the end.
- And heres the thing about this battle they win it and the overall war! without the aid of a jedi.
- The first order makes sense as a fascist reaction to the outcome of the galactic civil war which wasnt stomped down hard enough by the new liberal order, but ros is still completely batshit.
- Lucas wants us to empathise with anakin. The jedi have lost their way.
- The collapse of the jedi especially when you blend it in with what the clone war animated show teed up was just chefs kiss.
- I never understood why they decided to make the clones fight for the republic. Clone wars implies the jedi were fighting clones, not with with clones.
- Episode i should have ended with the clone wars beginning. Episode ii should have taken place at the height of the war and dived into the stresses it put on the republic, the jedi, and anakin.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.
4. El Conflicto Central: La Guerra Civil Galáctica y sus Consecuencias.
Se discute cómo la victoria rebelde en la trilogía original se logró sin la intervención directa de los Jedi en la batalla final, enfatizando el papel de la gente común, y cómo las secuelas posteriores a menudo confunden el estado de la guerra.
- Ive always loved how none of the jedi stuff actually affects the outcome of the war one iota in the end.
- And heres the thing about this battle they win it and the overall war! without the aid of a jedi.
- The first order makes sense as a fascist reaction to the outcome of the galactic civil war which wasnt stomped down hard enough by the new liberal order, but ros is still completely batshit.
- Lucas wants us to empathise with anakin. The jedi have lost their way.
- The collapse of the jedi especially when you blend it in with what the clone war animated show teed up was just chefs kiss.
- I never understood why they decided to make the clones fight for the republic. Clone wars implies the jedi were fighting clones, not with with clones.
- Episode i should have ended with the clone wars beginning. Episode ii should have taken place at the height of the war and dived into the stresses it put on the republic, the jedi, and anakin.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.
5. La Trilogía de Precuelas y la Guerra de los Clones.
Las precuelas son vistas como una exploración de la caída de la República y el ascenso del Imperio, con el conflicto de la Guerra de los Clones como un elemento central, aunque criticado por su enfoque en disputas comerciales y la falta de claridad sobre la culpabilidad de los Jedi.
- Lucas wants us to empathise with anakin. The jedi have lost their way.
- The collapse of the jedi especially when you blend it in with what the clone war animated show teed up was just chefs kiss.
- I never understood why they decided to make the clones fight for the republic. Clone wars implies the jedi were fighting clones, not with with clones.
- Episode i should have ended with the clone wars beginning. Episode ii should have taken place at the height of the war and dived into the stresses it put on the republic, the jedi, and anakin.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.
6. El Debate sobre la Calidad y el Tono de las Películas.
Existe un debate constante sobre qué película es la "mejor Star War", con menciones frecuentes a *Empire Strikes Back* y *A New Hope*, y una división notable sobre las películas de la era Disney, donde *The Last Jedi* es divisiva y *Rise of Skywalker* es ampliamente criticada.
- Fundamentally, is empire strikes back or a new hope the best star war and of disney films, is rogue one or last jedi better?
- And people can disagree on a star war and it doesnt matter i love the last jedi a lot of ppl hate it and thats cool because thats how art works.
- Ive generally been at least lightly entertained watching anything star war. Rise of skywalker is the exception.
- My personal if i was going to watch a star war how likely is it i would pick this one list tlj rotj esb anh tfa sometimes higher if im in a finnpoe kick tpm r1 big gap here solorots aotc literally never tros.