1. El Debate sobre la Definición de Violencia Verbal.
Una parte significativa de la discusión se centra en si las palabras deben considerarse una forma de violencia. Mientras algunos usuarios defienden que solo la fuerza física es violencia, otros argumentan que el lenguaje puede ser un precursor o incluso un acto de violencia psicológica, especialmente cuando se utiliza para justificar la agresión real.
- Words arent violence. Meanwhile anyone who says words i dont like are going to be subjected to legal repercussions.
- Words are not violence. Only violence is violence. To justify violence by pointing what he said condones it. Which is how we got here.
- Words are not violence. That is unsettling because they have always been the precursor to violence.
- Words are not violence, but your words calling our words violence actually are lol nice one joanne.
- Violence is so baked into our language i kind of do think a general rule against threats that arent directed at actual users is kind of dumb.
2. Inconsistencia y Sesgo en las Políticas de Moderación.
Los usuarios reportan una aplicación inconsistente de las reglas de las plataformas, especialmente en Bluesky y Reddit. Se critica que las publicaciones que utilizan hipérbole o sarcasmo político son censuradas rápidamente por "incitar a la violencia", mientras que las amenazas explícitas o la retórica violenta de figuras públicas o grupos específicos a menudo permanecen sin sanción, sugiriendo un doble estándar.
- Bluesky just deleted a very tame anti-charlie post of mine and sent me a whole email about how im glorifying violence. Not really, total bullshit but they cant bring themselves to ban actual violent bigots on this platform when swathes of people bring it to them directly.
- I got a 3 day ban from reddit today for typing the words. Fists. We all know what to do. But that prompting violence but videos of fights, or drunk drivers killing people on the freeway or wearing nazi outfit posts, are fine.
- Bluesky moderation has consistently shown that violence against someone for an immutable trait is totally fine while violence against someone for the actions they take isnt.
- The department of homeland security is straight posting fascist propaganda on bluesky, calling for violence with regular frequency but a brother is banned for making a pop culture reference is banned indefinitely. Thats pure bullshit.
- I got a strike from twitter for this post. The struck me because they were saying this is a violent post, but its a restriction of free speech. As an older person, to tar and feather someone was to run them out of office, and in no way do i advocate for violence.
3. Consecuencias por Humor y Referencias Culturales.
Numerosos casos de suspensión se deben a publicaciones que, aunque de mal gusto o agresivas, son interpretadas por los moderadores (a menudo automatizados) como amenazas literales. Esto incluye referencias a letras de canciones, chistes de comediantes o metáforas políticas, lo que genera frustración por la falta de consideración del contexto.
- I said something like, this shit is going to end in guillotines and got permanently banned for inciting violence. Morons cant tell the difference between warning and inciting.
- I got banned for 3 days last week for suggesting this! apparently, its hate speech and encouraging violence!
- I got a 3 day suspension from reddit. I believe the comment i made was, they deserve the hunger games that theyre trying to give the rest of us. Is that threatening violence?
- I got a 7 day ban from commenting due to suggesting violence. I said a rebellion on reddit with regard to horrific ceo behavior, as a satirical comment.
- Apparently, its due to the moderation team not getting johnny cash lyrical references such as i shot a man in reno, just to watch him die and not being able to tell them apart from actual threats of political violence.
4. Sospecha de Agentes Provocadores y Llamadas a la No Violencia.
Existe una fuerte preocupación entre los usuarios sobre la presencia de cuentas falsas o bots que intentan incitar a la violencia para desacreditar movimientos o justificar la represión. Muchos usuarios adoptan una política estricta de bloqueo y promueven activamente la resistencia no violenta como la estrategia más efectiva.
- Be careful, as there are many bots on bluesky, and bots often push for violence. Most sane people in the world know that violence is wrong and also that violence will not help anyone right now.
- I will not be engaging with anyone who qts this talking about how we need violence to end this metaphorical or literal and neither should you, thats what the feds want. Keep that shit off bluesky dot com.
- I have a recent social media policy that any account that seems to demandpush foradvocate people engage in violence is immediately suspect and an instablock for that reason.
- I will block everyone without note who shows weapons of any kind or shows violence in a way which implicates that violence will solve any problem.
- If you are listening to voices urging violence and revenge or trying to inspire copycat attacks, understand this you will not be a hero. You will not spark change.