1. La Contradicción: Una Líder Femenina en un Movimiento Misógino.
Los usuarios señalan la profunda ironía y aparente hipocresía de que Erika Kirk asuma el liderazgo de TPUSA. Su nombramiento contradice directamente las enseñanzas de su esposo, Charlie Kirk, quien promovía públicamente la subordinación de la mujer a roles domésticos y criticaba a las mujeres con carreras profesionales.
- How can erika take over tpusa? it goes against all that charlie kirk preached. Charlie kirk glorifies a life of subordination for women and girls.
- Apparently i’m the only person who finds it ironic that tpusa made erika kirk its ceo - literally the exact opposite of what her husband publicly preached.
- Erika kirk is about to take over tpusa and she has her own ministry… she’s the type of woman her husband told other women not to be.
- How can kirk's wife take over tpusa? it violates all that charlie advocated. "reject feminism. Submit to your husband. You’re not in charge." – discussing news of taylor swift & travis kelce’s engagement on the charlie kirk show, 26 august 2025.
2. Escepticismo sobre su Liderazgo y el Futuro de TPUSA.
Existe un escepticismo generalizado sobre la capacidad de Erika Kirk para dirigir la organización. Muchos creen que la base de seguidores de TPUSA, cultivada en una cultura de misoginia, no aceptará a una mujer como líder, lo que podría llevar al declive o la disolución del grupo sin la figura carismática de su fundador.
- I'm just really skeptical of his widow's success in leading tpusa when his whole base are united in their hated of women.
- The male leaders of tpusa will never let erika kirk run things. At best she will become a feature speaker at conferences among the 25 wannabe maga influencers tpusa regularly promotes.
- I wouldn’t be surprised if tpusa doesn’t even exist in a year. None of his followers are gonna care what a “foid” like his wife has to say.
- It's going to be really funny how quickly tpusa dies out with kirk's wife in charge, a whole lot of those guys are never going to see a woman as a real leader.
3. El "Grift": Acusaciones de Motivaciones Financieras.
Una opinión recurrente es que la principal motivación de Erika Kirk es económica. Se la acusa de querer mantener el control sobre la "mina de oro" que es TPUSA para asegurar su estilo de vida y continuar con el "grift" (estafa). Sus rápidas acciones para recaudar fondos y posicionarse como líder son vistas como una prueba de ello.
- Tpusa is an extremely prosperous enterprise that has made charlie kirk a multimillionaire. When i heard erika speak, it struck me she was also staking a claim to that enterprise.
- She’s using herself. Tpusa is a goldmine and she wants that to continue.
- Remains to be seen whether tpusa peters out, but she clearly sees it as a way to self-enrich, & doesn’t want to hand that over to others in the org.
- Posting video coffinside to twitter is peak grift. Just terrible people. Only reason she wants in on tpusa is because the house, cars, travel accounts, maids, assistants, and cash are all in the holdings company (ies).
4. Un Rol de Figura Decorativa: La Viuda como Símbolo.
Muchos especulan que Erika Kirk no ejercerá un poder real, sino que será utilizada como una figura decorativa. La imagen de la "viuda afligida" que continúa el legado de su "mártir" esposo es vista como una poderosa herramienta para generar simpatía y donaciones, mientras que el control real permanecerá en manos de los líderes masculinos de la organización.
- They are using her for sympathy to increase tpusa membership. Then she will say she's stepping down to spend more time with her kids and a man will take over.
- It was a foregone conclusion. The image of the bereaved widow, a blonde former beauty queen, carrying on her martyred husband’s noble cause just is too powerful for an outfit like tpusa to ignore. The board is all older white men. How much real power will she have?
- Some man is going to step in and take over tpusa. They’ll trot her out and let her speak from time to time, but for the most part, she’ll be sitting in the back bench.
- And tpusa has not only pushed for women to be "trad wives" but hypocritically made this pos widow there new figurehead.