1. La Financiación Activa del Odio Anti-Trans por J.K. Rowling.
La principal fuente de controversia es la declaración explícita de J.K. Rowling de que utiliza las ganancias de la franquicia Harry Potter para apoyar financieramente grupos y legislación que buscan socavar los derechos de las personas transgénero. Los usuarios enfatizan que comprar productos HP es una acción directa de complicidad.
- Jkr is scum and uses our money to fund anti-trans hate groups. People who give her money and like harry potter crap are killing trans people. Why is that so hard to understand??!
- Now that i have your attention, supporting j.k. Rowling gives her money that she uses to push through laws that adversely affect trans people and then gloat about it, so please dont do it.
- Shes also using her money to bankroll legal attacks on trans people all over the world, soo.
- She makes money still from us supporting her work and openly boasts about that money going to anti trans causes. Theres no way to ethically engage with the hp world anymore.
- This is the key point. Rowling is now loudly saying that she is funding anti trans projects - so there is no way people can claim theyre not complicit when they help her make more money.
- Shes taken to posting on socials asking for people to come forward that she can give money to so she can fund their anti-trans legal battles. Thats where all that harry potter money is going.
- She is saying she will use her money to make sure a bill gets passed. If you cant accept her anti trans bullshit as truth, then hate that she uses her money as a way to sway politicians.
2. El Dilema Moral del Consumo y el Boicot.
Existe un fuerte llamado a boicotear cualquier producto relacionado con Harry Potter, incluyendo juegos, libros y adaptaciones futuras. La comunidad argumenta que la separación del "arte del artista" es imposible cuando el dinero se destina directamente a causar daño. Se critica duramente a quienes continúan consumiendo la IP por "nostalgia" o "conveniencia".
- But when you spend new money on harry potter products youre knowingly funding an anti-trans bigot.
- Giving money to a billionaire who uses said money for anti-trans is to be anti-trans. If your excuse is i want to play a game i have no choice but to deem you morally bankrupt.
- Its crazy how someones a trans ally until it comes to not giving your money to jk rowling because uwu its harry potter.
- The set aside the art from the artist thing in this case is moot. Harry potter money now goes right to destroying the human rights of trans persons.
- Im going to make a further argument. I know a lot of us brought harry potter stuff before jo revealed herself as a virulent transpobe. If you had a book as a child or watched the films, your money with interest has been to fund trans hate.
- Buying anything hp related directly supports the transphobic bigot who uses her money made off of hp to attack trans people like myself. If you are still willing to buy hp shit, then you are a transphobe and should be called out as such. Cry more.
- Stop comsuming harry potter, i dont care how much of it was your childhood, you are the reason transphobes have money and your funko pops are ugly.
3. Críticas a Celebridades y Empresas Colaboradoras.
Se condena a actores, celebridades y empresas (como Lego o Warner Bros.) que participan en proyectos de Harry Potter, acusándolos de priorizar el dinero sobre los derechos humanos. Se les reprocha tomar "dinero de sangre" a pesar de ser conscientes de las acciones de Rowling.
- Celebrities who take hp money are saying they dont believe trans women and men and girls and boys deserve to exist. Fuck every one of them.
- If youre taking a job on a harry potter project, even if you say trans rights, im going to assume you did the math and decided you valued money over queer people and not buy your i couldnt have possibly known nonsense.
- The amount of celebrities like simon pegg, kit harrington, keira knightly, matt berry who are more than happy to take gigs that will contribute to transphobia is insane. Every actor ive named is a millionairre, they do not need the money.
- They all know and they are happy to help her make more money to be used against the trans community. They are all evil.
- They talk the talk, but the blood money they bank talks louder.
- Lego does not directly pay j.k. Rowling for licensing but the licensing money they pay to warner bros. Does indirectly support her, and she frequently points to the success of the books, movies, parks, and merch as an endorsement of her views.
- I think this response by keira knightley is probably more infuriating and contemptuous than if shed just said i simply dont care, i did it for the money.
4. Riqueza, Pobreza y la Lucha Transgénero.
El debate se amplía para abordar cómo la riqueza extrema permite a individuos como Rowling ejercer una influencia política desproporcionada para impulsar agendas de odio. Esto contrasta con la dificultad económica que enfrentan muchas personas trans para acceder a cuidados esenciales (HRT, cirugías) y la necesidad de apoyo financiero directo.
- Organized people beat organized money, but its real hard when that money is a fucking billionaire who has rotted her brain online reading propaganda about trans women.
- The fact that a billionaire, in this case jkrowling, has all the money in the world yet chooses to be chronically online fighting on the xitter about trans people tells me shes deeply, deeply, deeply unhappy.
- If i had the money id already be gone im literally afraid to tell people that im not a trump naga because i look like one because im a white male with a beard and people come up to me and just assume i am and start talking to me i hate it so much.
- A trans woman with a lot of money telling other trans women they are not making the effort to look feminine comes from a very privilege mindset. Not all trans women have a lot of money. Many dont and we cant just go and buy ourselves all the laser hair appointments and surgeries we want.
- If you wanna contribute to an actual cause that helps trans women, give me, a trans woman, money. Itll do more good than bitching about a cartoon because someone critiqued it or because the creator dared to answer a question honestly.
- Drugs cost a great deal of money, surgery as well. Every trans person i know pays for it themselves.
- I wish trans people had sufficient money for our lives to be as important as the opinions of transphobes.