1. La Controversia: Los Comentarios de Kirk y el Contraste de "Pertenencia".
Esta sección resume la reacción inicial a la afirmación de Charlie Kirk de que él y su familia "nunca se sintieron seguros" en la ciudad de Nueva York (NYC) debido a la presencia de personas que "no pertenecen allí". Los extractos invierten el argumento, afirmando que es el propio Kirk, un conservador y turista, quien no pertenece a la ciudad.
- Charlie kirk is the guy who said he and his family never felt safe visiting nyc because of all the people "who don't belong there".
- From this new yorker: charlie kirk does not belong in nyc - a very safe city - and he can stay the fuck in whatever rancid dumpster he crawled out of with his trash family.
- Charlie kirk is right - he and his family don't belong in nyc.
- Charlie kirk and his family are the people who don't belong in nyc. They belong in dumbfuckistan.
- The only person who doesn't belong in new york city is charlie kirk. Go the fuck home.
2. Acusaciones de Racismo, Xenofobia y Dog-Whistles.
La gran mayoría de los extractos interpretan la frase de Charlie Kirk sobre las personas que "no pertenecen" como un mensaje codificado o "silbato para perros" (dog-whistle) dirigido a la población no blanca, inmigrante o minoritaria de NYC. Los críticos lo acusan directamente de racismo y xenofobia.
- Charlie kirk says he didn't feel safe in nyc. Maybe, just maybe it's because he's a racist, xenophobic bigot who spews hate all day long and is truly despised by the good, hard working people of nyc.
- Of course, this is charlie kirk, so his "don't belong" comment is a telling dog whistle about immigration.
- Basically he doesn't feel safe around black and brown people with accents.
- Translation: charlie kirk saw nonwhite people. That is who he means by "do not belong".
- Charlie kirk, a child of the suburbs, says the increasing non-white population of nyc doesn't "belong there".
3. Desacreditando las Afirmaciones de Inseguridad con Datos y Experiencia.
Muchos extractos contrarrestan la narrativa de inseguridad de Kirk señalando que NYC es estadísticamente una ciudad muy segura, incluso más que su lugar de residencia (Arizona o Phoenix). Se destaca que la percepción de inseguridad de Kirk es infundada, performativa o el resultado de su propia mentalidad de "macho" conservador asustado.
- We just spent 3 nights in nyc. Never felt unsafe for even one second.
- Charlie kirk lives in a city with a 50% higher violent crime rate than nyc.
- Charlie kirk is a pos liar and trying to give cover to trump who's trying to destroy our sanctuary city and who's crime rate has dropped to the lowest levels in years.
- Charlie kirk: "manhattan is a criminal wasteland with shooting crimes happening on every corner at every hour, which i was brought my entire family along to vacation there. "although we witnessed no crimes, we were terrified the entire time...".
- Kirk lives in phoenix which last year had a homicide rate of 8.8 per 100k population while nyc's rate was 4.7.
4. Ataques Personales y Caracterizaciones Negativas a su Figura.
Una parte significativa del contenido consiste en ataques personales y epítetos dirigidos a Charlie Kirk, centrándose en su personalidad, apariencia y su postura política. Se le describe repetidamente como un "cobarde" o "nazi".
- Charlie kirk is a panty waist little crying maga moron.
- Charlie kirk is a moonfaced imbecile.
- The only fucker who "don't belong" in nyc is charlie kirk, bro. Abnormal no balls fake christian fascist asshole.
- Charlie kirk is such a stupid nazi fuck that he literally thinks "new york city would be so cool without the gays, and immigrants and blacks and jews".
- Charlie kirk is weaker than wet toilet paper.
- Charlie kirk: the world's smallest thumb-faced coward.