1. La Falsedad de la División Geográfica Clara.
Muchos comentaristas argumentan que la división política no se alinea estrictamente con las fronteras estatales, sino que existe una mezcla de ideologías dentro de cada estado, a menudo reflejando una división urbano-rural.
- Smh, people no! the political division is not drawn on state borders, blue vs red states. That scenario was a different civil war. Today, there are several millions of people in so-called red states who dont support the maga coup, and several millions of maga in so-called blue states.
- Except theres really no such thing as red states and blue states. People from all sides live everywhere. Further division doesnt make anyone stronger.
- That is impossible. Its not 1860. Red states are full of blue cities. Blue states are full of red rural counties. There is no workable division of the country.
- Op march 30, 2025 there arent any red states. There arent any blue states. Every state is purple. Every family is purple. Lets put an end to all of the fabricated division.
- Just a reminder there are no red or blue states. This is an artificial division created by an antiquated electoral college. In every state are liberals, conservatives, independents, apathetic people who didnt vote. Every division hurts us. Every state protested on oct 18, 2025.
2. La División como Táctica Política y Distracción.
Existe una fuerte creencia de que la narrativa de "estados rojos contra estados azules" es promovida activamente por actores políticos (a menudo asociados con Trump/MAGA) para distraer a la población de problemas económicos o para consolidar el poder.
- They have us focused on red and blue states. Thats not a real thing. Theyve created this division. We are all more nuanced as humans. We are neighbors. We all want a safe and secure place to raise our families. Wake up to the farce. Love thy neighbor.
- I need to know why they cant work in a red state? all this division is not helping the situation. Its another way of dividing people . They are using us against each other. Thats how it works. Youre falling for the psychological warfare.
- So-called blue states vs red states is not our narrative, its their narrative. They want liberals and dems to spread it, to help along their division of this one nation along state lines, and to legitimize and advance their states rights bullshit. I will not comply.
- The leadership is actively creating a division of the population defined by a view of what it is to be american. You guys are heading towards civil war.
- Division is not leadership. We must unite against this madness.
3. Llamadas a la Secesión o Divorcio Nacional.
Ante la profundidad del conflicto y la percepción de que el país es ingobernable, algunos usuarios proponen seriamente la secesión de los estados azules o un "divorcio nacional" como única salida pacífica para evitar una guerra civil.
- It is time to seriously consider secession of blue states. The legacy of division from the civil war persists and has been fomented by maga. The country is inextricably divided and ungovernable.
- Embrace the division. Red states and blue states need to go their separate ways. Timmer for president.
- It is time to seriously consider secession of blue states. The legacies of the civil war have never healed and it is difficult to consider healing the division between red and blue. Better to do this now and avoid civil war and deaths and destruction. Country is ungovernable.
- I have given up on half of america. I do not think we will ever be able to reconcile after current events. We have extraordinarily different visions and values. Im for a division of red blue states, with a fund for people to relocate where they most align.
- I think that the red stateblue state thing should be put on a back burner. Both parties suck. If we cant work together to change the systems that oppress us all, the fascists currently in power win. They gain power through sowing division, distraction miseducation. Our liberation is connected.
4. La División como Causa de la Inacción y el Conflicto Histórico.
Varios comentarios trazan paralelos con conflictos históricos, como la Guerra Civil, y señalan que la división actual impide resolver problemas reales y que la retórica divisiva es un patrón recurrente en la historia estadounidense.
- We did that once and over 500 people died.
- States fighting states - citizens fighting each other . I feel like all this division is just feeding those who could like this country to fail .
- The reps would love this, division of the states with the lower educated majority in the red ones. Sounds like the beginning of an internal struggle.
- The problem though, is that the division between blue and red states is not remotely as easily-divided as it was during our first civil war. The factions are scattered. And most states dont have quite enough military might unto themselves to stand against the federal. Its gonna be messy.
- History has no shortage of states that have used division as a survival tactic, turning the peoples frustration sideways instead of upward. These should all sound very frighteningly familiar.