1. La IA como simulacro y juego de lenguaje.
Una gran parte de las opiniones sostiene que la inteligencia artificial carece de conciencia real, funcionando únicamente como un sofisticado sistema de predicción estadística que imita el comportamiento humano sin comprensión interna.
- Ai is not conscious, it is just a complex language game designed to imitate human responses and use probability to fake through to the best one.
- Ai currently is just doing what humans are telling it to do, by what humans are telling it to learn from. From the outside it seems its thinking for itself. Its really not.
- It is a linguistic prediction machine that does not think and is hyper corporatized so much it cant even do good linguistic prediction half the fucken time.
- Ai is not intelligence. It is statistical prediction at scale. Strategy begins when we stop anthropomorphizing tools.
2. El dilema de la definición de conciencia.
El debate se complica debido a la falta de un consenso científico y filosófico sobre qué constituye la conciencia, lo que genera escepticismo ante las afirmaciones de sentiencia por parte de las empresas tecnológicas.
- Humanity does not have a technical definition of consciousness so we cant possibly know if an ai model gains consciousness.
- Its crazy how so many ppl have bought into the idea that ai is close to consciousness, a thing that literally nobody on earth understands or has ever understood.
- The question is the ai conscious? keeps getting asked as if it has a yesno answer. But stentor, planarians, and octopuses have already shown us that mind comes in degrees.
- We dont even understand human consciousness, so every ai bro claiming that ai might be conscious is simply revealing their fetish.
3. Crítica al marketing y la terminología engañosa.
Muchos usuarios denuncian que el término "Inteligencia Artificial" es una metáfora de marketing diseñada para mistificar el software y ocultar procesos que son puramente matemáticos o, en algunos casos, dependientes de labor humana oculta.
- Artificial intelligence is a marketing metaphor. It suggests that engineers have synthesized intellect. Thats nonsense. Ai isnt actually smart.
- I wish companies would stop referring to algorithms as ai. It completely poisons the well when talking about new technology.
- Ai is a deliberately misleading term and has always been. People knowledgeable on the subject know that its not literal.
- Ai is smoke and mirrors. There is a tragic human cost. It is hidden intelligence. Slave labor. Inhumane conditions for human workers powering the machines.
4. La importancia de la corporalidad y la emoción.
Se argumenta que la verdadera conciencia requiere de una base biológica, sentidos físicos y la capacidad de experimentar emociones reales, elementos de los que carecen los sistemas basados en silicio.
- Human knowing is inextricably linked to human feeling, sensing. It goes both ways. Ai does not and cannot feel.
- Ai cannot experience spontaneous happiness or sadness, it can only pretend to have emotions based upon an algorithm. Human emotions are far more complex.
- Unless and until an ai has a nervous system and a physical sense of self, it will be incapable of experiencing anything analogous.
- A program that cannot refuse to interact with humans will not develop consciousness. The possibility of death may bring ai closer to human consciousness.
5. La IA como espejo de la cognición humana.
Más que una nueva forma de vida, la IA es vista como una herramienta que refleja nuestras propias capacidades y sesgos, obligándonos a cuestionar qué es lo que realmente nos hace humanos.
- Ai successfully mimicked human intelligence and ignorance. Its shocking stupidity is simply our ignorance being mirrored back.
- The real discovery may not be that ai can fool us into thinking it has a sense of self, but that weve been fooling ourselves into thinking we do.
- What i dislike about ai is that it doesnt know what it doesnt know. It has no model of its own mind.
- Ai is incredible because its trained on the sum of humanity. But its outputs are the average of humanity, not its peak.