1. La distinción necesaria entre la IA tradicional y la generativa.
Los usuarios manifiestan una frustración constante ante la simplificación del término "IA", defendiendo las herramientas analíticas y de optimización mientras condenan específicamente los modelos generativos por su naturaleza destructiva.
- Really big pet peeve of mine equating generative ai with regular ai, and in the process simplifying things down to ai bad. I wish people would specifically that its specifically gen ai that theyre against, because thats the one thats actively destructive.
- Not all ai is generative ai. Ai of this type has been around for decades. I worked for a company using ai to identify cancer 25 years ago. Unfortunately the hot garbage of genai has polluted conversations around ai in general.
- I wish the media had adopted separate terms for generative ai, llms and machine learning from the start, because the last two have tons of benign uses, and in my opinion gen ai has no ethical use.
2. El imperativo ético frente al plagio y el robo de propiedad intelectual.
La crítica principal se centra en que la IA generativa no crea, sino que extrae y recombina obras humanas sin consentimiento, funcionando como una maquinaria de plagio a escala industrial.
- Generative ai is a piss poor attempt to capitalize on stealing the work of real people and intentionally dumbing people down to manipulate them into doing what major companies want them to do.
- Gen ai is theft. It steals from artists who never gave it permission, and artists long passed who never had the chance to. There is no ethical reason to use it. None.
- Ai is a tool, not the entire creative process. Generative ai is just the creative process, and it cant be creative, it just steals other peoples work without citing or crediting sources.
3. El costo ambiental: Energía, agua y la destrucción del ecosistema.
Se denuncia el impacto ecológico devastador de los centros de datos necesarios para procesar estos modelos, señalando el consumo excesivo de agua potable y electricidad en medio de una crisis climática global.
- All generative ai is bad. Its all ruining the environment. Its all theft. None of it is able to be claimed as artwork or unique or able to be copy written.
- The only good use for it is if your intent is burning money, polluting air and evaporating lakes.
- I am beyond concerned by the water crisis, on top of climate crisis. Its the easiest step to just stop all use of gen ai, there is 0 benefit there.
4. Impacto en la cognición humana y la desvalorización del pensamiento crítico.
Existe una preocupación profunda por cómo la dependencia de estas herramientas está atrofiando las capacidades intelectuales y creativas de las nuevas generaciones, fomentando la pereza mental.
- Using genai makes you stupid. It makes you less creative and turns you into uninteresting clone. I really didnt need a study for this i can just look at those shilling for ai.
- Generative ai has made it worse because it allows the younger generation to not think. Why put in the effort when a machine can do it for you?
- By abdicating thinking - or intelligence as some of the ai proponents call it - to genai, we lose the capability to think for ourselves, whether individuals, firms, cultures, or states.
5. Resistencia cultural contra el "slop" y la desconfianza corporativa.
El término "slop" (desperdicio) se ha consolidado para describir el contenido generado por IA, provocando un rechazo visceral hacia las empresas que intentan normalizar su uso en productos comerciales.
- Generative ai is a tool to discipline, then eliminate, the human worker. The audience will just have to get used to it. This is sold as progress. Fuck ai.
- If you use gen ai slop at any point during the creative process, im not interested in buying, playing, watching, reading, or listening to your thing.
- I am so really sick of how much generative ai gets used on here. There is no reason. Either fake pictures like this or some stupid little twinkly ai to say good morning or whatever.