1. El rechazo visceral a la música sintética y la pérdida del alma artística.
La mayoría de los usuarios expresan una fuerte aversión hacia la música generada por IA, calificándola como "basura" o "slop" (desperdicio), argumentando que carece de la emoción y el esfuerzo que definen al arte humano.
- I do not want to listen to ai in any music i enjoy. I understand some people are using it as a tool to make their stuff better but its not what i would call an authentic tool. The creative process is hard and thats why it works, it brings out our best.
- Ai sucks. When you ask it to create a song that lyrically and musically fuses all of the pop music hits of the 1980s... It tries to refer me instead to a rihanna song from 2008. Worthless.
- Ai only produces content. Flat, bland content. Background noise. Elevator music. No one really wants that.
- I'd rather listen to the worst most incompetent music made by a human than the most polished, produced ai slop music.
2. La crisis de autenticidad y el sentimiento de traición al descubrir contenido IA.
Existe un patrón recurrente de decepción entre los oyentes que, tras disfrutar de una canción, descubren que es producto de una IA, lo que genera una sensación de haber sido engañados o "estafados".
- Im so sick of finding a new song i love only to find out its ai. So far ive found two different creators who claim they wrote the lyrics but used ai for everything else.
- I just got fooled by an ai musician. I feel violated? I used to love finding new real music and artists, and that was just snatched from me.
- The sudden betrayal when i start jamming to a new song i like then find out its actually ai generated trash.
- Found out that more than a few of the songs ive been listening to lately are from musicians who engage with ai to varying degrees. And i want to clarify again- if you willingly use ai, i think less of you.
3. Desafíos en plataformas digitales: Fraude, etiquetado y saturación.
Los usuarios denuncian la inundación de servicios como Spotify, YouTube y Deezer con miles de pistas generadas automáticamente, lo que dificulta la visibilidad de artistas reales y facilita fraudes de regalías.
- Deezer says ai song uploads have nearly overtaken human music. Deezer says it receives nearly 75,00 ai-generated song submissions to its music streaming platform each day.
- Spotify tests new tool to stop ai slop from being attributed to real artists. Finally, a step in the right direction to combat ai-generated audio duplication.
- Youtube pushing fake ai genre albums is so insidious. The people that create them should be pulped.
- Someone used its like ai to critique the new bruno mars album and i was like dude, seriously? Ai is not a term reviewers should just be throwing around like its nothing.
4. El debate sobre el uso ético: Herramientas de producción vs. generación total.
Mientras que la generación completa de canciones es ampliamente rechazada, existe un debate matizado sobre el uso de IA para tareas técnicas como la separación de pistas (stems) o la restauración de audio.
- I know this is one of those instances where ai is being used as a tool and its supposed to be helpful to musicians but ughh.
- The only ethical use of ai in music would be using it to extend a song that ends sooner than you want it to!!
- I think that unlike writing and art the music community has embraced ai and it is not even different than existing techniques like auto tune, vocal oils, sampling etc.
- Stem splitting ai is hell yeah. Ai that looks at my piano roll and suggests melodic extensions and backing chords is also hell yeah nut its touchy. Ai that vibes my entire song is hell no.
5. La defensa de los espacios humanos y el futuro de la industria.
Como respuesta a la proliferación de la IA, surge un movimiento de apoyo a plataformas que prohíben este contenido, como Bandcamp, y una revalorización de las presentaciones en vivo.
- Bandcamp is a good place to go for recommendations. That platform does not allow ai-generated music.
- Live music and curation will be the things that separates the real musicians and artists from ai creators.
- I'd never pay 100 for a ticket to see a stage with a data-centre on it. I have no issue with electronic music, but ill only watch a performance if theres a human at the controls.
- Support bands and artists who are humans and work hard to make art. That is all.