1. La deshumanización del proceso creativo.
Los usuarios enfatizan que el arte es un proceso intrínsecamente humano que requiere intención, emoción y esfuerzo, elementos que la tecnología no puede replicar.
- I fully support human art and think that the humanity in it is what makes it so special.
- Art is inherently human, its creation directly informed by our experiences, passions, perspective, and hardships. It costs us something that cant be machine-generated.
- Exactly! ai has no soul or charm to what it does. We humans do, and we always will. And as a wise man once said, you cant rush art.
2. El conflicto ético: Plagio y robo de propiedad intelectual.
Existe un consenso generalizado sobre la naturaleza extractiva de los modelos de IA, los cuales se entrenan con obras protegidas por derechos de autor sin consentimiento ni compensación.
- Ai art is trained on stolen artwork - its fundamentally un-creative and disrespectful to real human artists.
- These companies are blatantly laundering copyrighted artwork, displacing the artists they stole from, devaluing the arts as a whole. Fuck ai.
- The images are literally stolen from every other piece of art or photo or cartoon thats been uploaded to the internet.
3. El clima de desconfianza y las falsas acusaciones.
La proliferación de imágenes generadas por IA ha creado una atmósfera de paranoia donde artistas legítimos deben defender constantemente la autenticidad de su trabajo manual.
- The main thing that depresses me about ai is the turmoil it creates toward actual artists. People see imperfections in art and wrongly accuse the artist for using ai, when its in fact, hand drawn.
- It gets a little bit heartbreaking when someone thinks my stuff is ai. No wonder ive really lost my passion for making images, i think whats the point?
- Randomly accusing artists of using ai, when they have not in fact done so, is doing the work of the ai boosters. Because it destroys the reputations of actual artists.
4. Impacto económico y desplazamiento del mercado laboral.
Los profesionales del sector reportan una caída drástica en las solicitudes de comisiones y una tendencia corporativa a priorizar la rapidez sobre la calidad artística.
- Ai is destroying the commission art market. Ive not had a single commission request since ai launched.
- Sorry, but there is nothing to appreciate about ai art. All its doing is taking away artists jobs.
- If you use ai to generate imagery for your product game, movie, poster, music, etc it makes it look and feel cheap. It also proves you were cheap for not using a real artist.
5. La IA como herramienta técnica frente al concepto de "Slop".
Mientras una minoría ve potencial en la IA para tareas de apoyo, la mayoría rechaza su uso en la creación final, calificando el resultado como contenido vacío o "basura digital".
- Ai is just another tool that can be used by an artist. Garbage in garbage out. Put time and skill in and beauty out.
- I dont mind brainstorming or philosophical work with ai but using ai as official art in place of creative talent? ew. Im sorry.
- This is why i dont mind the term ai slop, because ai art really only looks good if you dont particularly care about what your looking at.
6. El valor del error y la imperfección humana.
Frente a la perfección sintética de los algoritmos, los creadores reivindican la belleza de los fallos y la técnica tradicional como prueba de vida y autenticidad.
- I want to see the imperfections that tell me a human made this.
- Art is meant to be flawed. No matter how well detailed it is. Because it shows how much hard work and commitment the artist puts themselves in.
- The problem with ai in art is that its trying to perfect something that cant be perfected. Arts imperfections are why its perfect.